Strawberry Vanilla Ice Cream Pie

strawberry vanilla pie.png

This Pie is a delightful mix of cold sweetness and cookie crunch.

This is my 2nd time making this yummy dessert. This dessert is an adaptation from the posted recipe from Life Made Sweeter.

My family requested this pie as the days are getting warmer and their taste buds are switching from warm desserts to cooler ones.

I made this pie in an 8 x 8 pan. I find that it’s easier to cut equal pieces and we don’t make too much dessert, since only 3 out of 5 of us eat it (my little ones don’t like strawberry ice cream).
I let this chill overnight and when it was ready, I cut it into 12 smaller pieces. While the pieces are small, the dessert goes farther (or so you would think) between the 3 of us.
The first piece went to hubby. He is the one who originally wanted a dessert like this, so I let him make sure it tastes ok. My oldest however, is a fiend for this dessert. He raved to his friends about it and so when I told him it was ready, the next 4 pieces went to he and his friends. I was able to get 2 out of the 12 pieces of this dessert over the course of a week.
Hubby made sure that he got the last piece, claiming “dibs”, when he found out there was only 1 left.

This dessert can be made in so many ways. I have had the request to replace the strawberry ice cream with mint chocolate chip, the next time I make it.

Strawberry Vanilla Ice Cream Pie

Description of Recipe

Makes: 12 Servings

Name of image (title of post is fine)

Prep time:

Cook/Chill time:

  • 20 Golden Oreo Cookies (or any Vanilla Creme Sandwich Cookies) Equivalent to 2 cups crushed with creme
  • 3 Tablespoons Melted Butter
  • 5 Cups Vanilla Ice Cream (your choice)
  • 3 cups Strawberry Ice Cream (your choice)

  • 10 Golden Oreo Cookies (or any Vanilla Creme Sandwich Cookies) Equivalent to 1 cup crushed with creme
  • 1 Tablespoon Melted Butter

  1. Make Cookie Crust - In a food processor, add cookies (creme & cookie) and pulse into fine crumbs
  2. Pour into a bowl with melted butter and stir until combined.
  3. Press into an 8x8 or 9x13 baking sheet. Place in freexer for 20 minutes to set.
  4. Make Crumbled topping. Place cookies into a zip lock bag & crush into large, but bite sized crumbs. Set aside.
  5. Allow Vanilla and Strawberry Ice Creams to soften (about 20 minutes on the counter)
  6. When Ice cream is ready, remove crust from freezer.
  7. When Ice cream is ready, remove crust from freezer.
  8. Place crust and vanilla ice cream pan in freezer for 15 minutes.
  9. Scoop 3 coops of strawberry Ice Cream and layer over vanilla Ice Cream.
  10. Place crust and vanilla/strawberry ice cream pan in freezer for 15 minutes.
  11. Add final layer of remain vanilla ice cream over the strawberry ice cream, spreading evenly.
  12. Sprinkle cookie crumbs from ziploc bag over the top layer.
  13. Place pie back into freezer for a minimum of 4 hours, but best overnight.
  14. Cut pieces as desired and serve.
Tara FunairComment